Friday, September 10, 2010

In the shadow of the World Trade Center



I remember almost nothing about the morning of September 11th. It was my son's first day of school, but I don't recall thinking about that on my way to the office that morning. A huge black and silver banner hung from the face of the New York Stock Exchange; it read Blackwood. I remember the sign because my company was Blackwood. The sign, however, was an advertisement for a forthcoming truck from Lincoln. I don't recall looking at the sign that morning. I don't remember the walk up to the tower at 40 Wall and I do not recall my agenda for the day.

The first thing I remember was Adam's announcement as he came into the office, "A bomb just went off at the Trade Center!"
Adam's deep voice belies his small frame, but his accent is a true indicator of his roots. He has lived his entire life in New York City, settling down in a Staten Island townhome. It was unusual for him to be one of the first to arrive in the morning. He had side projects recording music and writing game software that kept him up late. This time he was a little early, and he got to break the news. "I saw it. It's a mess out there."

Together we rushed to the windows to look. The sky all around us was filled with paper; eight and a half by eleven sheets drifting in the air like a strange high-rise ticker tape parade. From the top of the Trade Center's North Tower, a thick black cloud rose into the bright blue sky.

Blackwood had offices spanning two floors high in the tower at 40 Wall Street. Surrounding the offices on three sides were large windows offering panoramic views of lower Manhattan's canyons. Across the length of the floors, the windows faced west toward the Hudson River. Standing at these windows you looked up at the massive twin towers standing tall and dwarfing the surrounding buildings. From our vantage on the 30th floor, the south tower was mostly unobstructed while only the top third of the north tower was visible.

I watched the smoke and flames for a minute then turned to the televisions. Blackwood had an extensive and modern trading floor including several televisions monitoring financial news. As it was well before the market open, the sets were tuned to MSNBC. That's how we discovered an airplane had hit Tower One. From our windows, we could not see the point of impact, but the news showed the tower with the impact clearly in the shape of an airplane.

"How could a plane hit the Trade Center?" I barely uttered the words, not expecting an answer.

We stared at the televisions and speculated about private planes. Probably a tourist flight.

I called my wife to give her the news. Susan had worked in the World Financial Center, just across the West Side Highway from the Trade Center. She often recalled the time fondly, describing her favorite hangouts. She loved the towers and remembered vividly the day they were bombed. I was telling her to turn on the news when the second airplane struck the towers.
The second impact made a very distinctive sound. It was higher pitched than a Hollywood explosion and only lasted a fraction of a second. Imagine the sound a large dump truck makes when its gate slams against an empty bed. I turned toward the windows as my staff yelled a collective "oh my God!" Melba, our receptionist made the sign of the cross.

I did not see the impact, and for a minute no one could describe it to me. I told Susan I had to hang up the phone and went to the windows. As I did, Dan came into the office. He was covered in debris, little pieces of glass, paper, and dust.

"It was a missile!" he claimed. "A greenish-brown missile, like it was camouflage. I was watching from the end of Wall Street when it hit."

Dan worked with our back-office systems and was primarily responsible for seeing Blackwood meet its compliance requirements. He was not prone to exaggeration, and he was clearly shaken. Our entire staff lined the windows, mesmerized.
The company's CEO was a long-time investment banker who had come from J.P. Morgan through a failed Internet startup. John hailed from the Carolinas attending Duke University along the way. He still spoke with a southern accident, occasionally peppered with New York street talk. The combination never seemed natural. He stood with his hands on his hips for a minute, then rallied the staff away from the windows. The markets opened as normal at 9:30am and for a short time it looked like it would be business as usual.

"Dmitry called in," our admin Melba came over relaying a message, "his train was held at Newark."

Dmitry was a Russian immigrant with a warm smile and freckles. He is soft spoken, intelligent, and punctual. And when his PATH train to the World Trade Center was canceled, he found another route into the city. From his commuter train in Newark, New Jersey, he could see the smoke from the Towers. He had promised to arrive at the office before the trading floor had opened, but the trains were delayed, and he would be late. He dutifully called the office from his cell phone.

On a normal day, Dmitry would change trains in Newark, moving from the NJ Transit commuter train to the PATH. The PATH went directly to the World Trade Center where it was a short walk to Blackwood's offices at 40 Wall. But with the PATH temporarily shut down, he stayed on the commuter train to Penn Station in New York City.
From there he fought through the crowds and chaos to the Mass Transit Authority's 1 and 9 subway line. The 1 and 9 were downtown express trains with a station at the World Trade Center. He found the trains were crowded but running. Dmitry squeezed into a subway car and headed downtown.

Back at 40 Wall Street, news of the Pentagon attack spread like wildfire. For the first time, there was true fear among the employees. Adam expressed panic and a desire to leave. Immediately. John and I calmed him a little.

"You don't know what kind of shit is falling out of the sky now," John stated with some authority. "We're safer inside."

But the fear was real. Two of the tallest buildings in the world were burning, the Pentagon was under attack, and at least one more plane was unaccounted for. At that moment, in downtown New York City, we believed that rogue jetliners were screaming toward us. I became acutely aware that next to the World Trade Center, I was standing in the tallest building in lower Manhattan.

The Institutional Sales desk had the best view of the burning towers. From his desk, our lead salesman Kirk watched the flames intently. The fire was hypnotic, and once it attracted our attention, we were powerless to turn away. Kirk and I stared at the flames, commenting on their intensity, and wondering how the Fire Department would ever put them out.

I turned to speak with another executive as Kirk shouted out, "Did you see that?! Someone jumped!" I turned and thankfully, saw nothing.

I returned my attention to the other executive when he asked "Has anyone heard from Karen? She is attending a conference at the Windows on The World."

Karen was Blackwood's marketing executive. She was attractive, outgoing, and extremely effective. On September 11th she was scheduled to attend a seminar where she hoped to spread the Blackwood story.

Karen lived in Battery Park City, just blocks from the World Trade Center. Not an early riser, she had taken her time leaving home for the short walk to the Trade Center. The seminar was at The Windows on the World, on the top floor of Tower One. She reached the lobby of the north tower shortly after nine in the morning, only to discover the building was being evacuated. With no explanation she was directed outdoors. Everyone who was on time for the seminar had only an hour to live.

She started back across the West Side Highway toward home, contemplating whether to go to the office when the second plane exploded into the south tower. The explosion shook the crosswalk where she stood, but her view of the tower was blocked. Through the small windows she could see debris raining down on the street below. During the ensuing panic she thought it best to head to Battery Park. From there she could enjoy the sunny morning and watch what was happening at the World Trade Center.

At Blackwood Kirk and I were observing the fires. He was glued to the windows morbidly looking for more jumpers. We saw none.

We could clearly see the point of impact on the south tower. We could also see the areas where the explosion had blown out windows in both towers. There were few windows intact on the damaged floors creating an eerie effect where the upper floors of each building were held up by the ribs that formed the skeleton of the building. Thick black smoke poured from the open floors. Huge orange and yellow flames covered entire floors.

For a moment I thought the flames were dying down in the north tower. I pointed them out to Kirk, saying that the fire was starting to burn itself out in Tower One. But Kirk's eyes were riveted to Tower Two.

"I think bars are bending..." he was pointing to the south tower, but I couldn't see what he was pointing at. Then in slow motion the top third of Tower Two tilted directly toward us.

"My God! It's coming down!" Kirk barely got the words out of his mouth when Tower Two imploded, collapsing straight down on itself as if the bottom floor was kicked out from beneath it. Within seconds our building was covered in a thick black cloud. We could no longer see either tower.

Down in the subway tunnels, Dmitry's train stopped short of the Chambers Street station. The train did not move for several minutes when the lights flickered and went dark. Even in the blackness, Dmitry could see the train car filled with a dust cloud. Passengers started screaming.

In a brief time that must have seemed like hours, the lights came on and the train started moving. At Chambers street the conductor announced that the train was out of service. All passengers must exit. Dmitry shuffled out of the crowded train, following the flow of people through the turnstiles and up the stairs to the street.

On the street was pandemonium. Sirens wailed, people were running, and the ground was covered with light gray dust. There was only one tower at the World Trade Center. A policeman shouted at him to leave and to run, so he ran. He ran and ran, not stopping until he reached the lawn of City Hall. There he turned to watch.

In the office, Blackwood was still trading stocks, but we were huddled around the televisions as we could not see through the foggy cloud surrounding us.

"I can't believe there is only one tower" Melba was almost crying, or she was too shocked to cry.

"If one came down, the other is probably going to come down too," I replied. I called my wife one more time to let her know I was safe. From my office I watched the live news as Tower One collapsed. Then the phone went dead.

The cloud surrounding us changed from gray to black. Pure pitch black. Blacker than coal and blacker than night. I could not see more than an inch out the window. For the first time I felt a real pang of fear as I checked the air conditioning ducts to make sure the dust was not pouring into the office.

"Give it a couple minutes, it will clear up" the CEO tried to be reassuring. "Maybe the dust will snuff out the fires."
We held a short meeting of executives to plan for the inevitable closing of business. The CEO wanted a clear plan for shutting down our computer servers, but first we needed to create reports on the customer's trades and positions. I suggested we plan to provide the staff with housing for the night. Those living in the city volunteered their apartments for those living in New Jersey or Long Island.

For Karen, Battery Park was becoming a problem. Crowds of panicked people flowed into the park by the thousands. She found herself forced deeper and deeper into the park to avoid the throng. At the furthest point she ran out of space and became pinned to the barrier that prevented the crowd from being pushed into New York harbor.

There was no escape or moving from her position. One man nearby climbed over the rail, briefly considered jumping into the water, then perched himself on the narrow ledge. There were boats nearby, only twenty feet away, but the water was dangerous and there was no mooring. She had to wait.

Shortly after our meeting, the New York Fire Department made it official. The building was being evacuated. The CEO and General Counsel were the first out the door, rushing to make a morning ferry back to Long Island. Most others quickly but orderly packed their things and headed for the stairs. The elevators were not running.

I stayed behind with Mike, the Director of Operations. He started shutting down our computers and I made sure the office was empty. Sure enough, on the trading floor, a trader remained at his workstation furiously banging at his keys. He was trying to close his positions before he left the building. When Mike shut down the system, the trader packed up his things, slung his backpack over this shoulder, and made for the stairs. I locked the doors behind him.

Mike and I were the last to leave the offices, making sure everyone was gone, and every door locked. By the time we left, the stairwell was mostly empty and was very easy to descend. We quickly descended ten to twenty flights before reaching a pack of stragglers. Together our little group slowly made our way to the first floor, exiting near the rear of the building. Security ushered us out the back door.

Outside, downtown Manhattan had been transformed into a surreal moonscape. There was a strange and total absence of color, only shades of gray. Looking west down Pine Street, toward the Trade Center, the streets were black as night. We trudged through the ankle-deep dust, making our way to the FDR highway. There, we were told, were shuttle buses to take us out of downtown. It was eerily silent.

I caught up with Mike, and we explored our options for getting off the Island of Manhattan. We could go to the FDR. Or we could make our way to the Village where one of our executives had offered his apartment for the night. On a whim, Mike suggested the ferries at Pier 11, so we turned right at Water Street instead of following the crowd uptown.

The dock at Pier 11 was busy, but not crowded. For me, the Seastreak ferry was docked and idling its' engine. The shipmates were calling all comers; there would be no charge for the trip. As I boarded the ferry for Atlantic Highlands, Mike found the New York Ferry to Jersey City waiting. In little more than an hour, I was home.

Everyone at Blackwood survived that day, but unfortunately, the company would not. Those of us in the office remained safe during the attacks, and everyone returned home that day. Dmitry and Karen, whose lives were spared by little more than 10 minutes, escaped their ordeal. Karen could not return to her apartment for weeks and eventually moved to New Jersey. By the following summer, none of us worked at Blackwood or even downtown Manhattan.

Thursday, February 26, 2009

Thoughts on Safari (browser)


I just downloaded and installed the
Safari 4 browser from Apple and it is, well, ugly! The ugliness is particularly bad on the rendering of its' tabs. The tabs are integrated into the window title bar with clumsy 3-D affects. It also eschews the former brushed aluminum theme for drab beige. I find this particularly disturbing since the software comes from one of the few technology companies that actually pays attention to design.

I was able to mitigate the ugliness a little by hiding the menu, bookmarks, and status bars. However, there's no changing the tabs. At first I rationalized the look in two ways. One, the software is beta so the appearance of the UI may change And two, Apple may be taking digs at Microsoft's Windows XP operating system. On further thought, neither makes sense as Apple should never risk its' reputation for design by releasing ugly software, especially on the most common desktop OS in the world.

That's not to say that Safari isn't a great web browser, it is innovative on a few fronts. First among these is speed, but does the average web surfer notice the speed of their browser? Maybe not, but the speed of Safari allows its' top page and history features to display and scroll pages. This works much like the CoolIris add-in (for IE and Firefox). I've only had Safari for a couple of hours, and I've already found the history search very useful.

The browser wars are heating up again and it's getting interesting. Internet Explorer 8, Chrome, FireFox, and Safari are all great software each with a compelling story. As for me, I use Explorer for all our intranet applications and Chrome as my default browser.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Tweetdeck

I've been using TweetDeck lately to submit my Twitter tweets. At first this seemed like a convenient way to tweet in absence of the instant messaging capability. While that is true, TweetDeck's real benefit comes in reading the tweets that I follow.

I always found the Twitter website a little clumsy for reading the streams of messages. That's because Twitter presents a single thread of messages displayed in the order they were posted. So my technology messages are intermixed with world news intermixed with gossips intermixed with nonsense. The result amounted to little more than noise.

TweetDeck solves this problems by grouping related tweets into columns. I separated technology and new into their own columns, for instance. Since installing TweetDeck, I find that I follow Twitter much more consistently (well OK, I generally ignored it before).

TweetDeck is also interesting because it is constructed and deployed on Adobe Air. Adobe Air runs Internet applications outside a browser and it therefore an interesting technology solving the multi-browser problem (which is getting worse, not better).

Atlantis found?

CrunchGear posted a blog indicating that Atlantis has been found. Sure, the source is a British tabloid, but apparently the ancient city was found using Google Earth.

While Atlantis is interesting in and of itself, the real story here is the technology. Google has been collecting data on the ocean floors using sonar. Impressive as it is that Google hired drivers to snap pictures of our major cities, it is even more incredible that they have hired boats to gather data about the ocean floor and stitch that data into their maps.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Don’t think of BI as an all-in-one solution

I recently had a short conversation on Business Intelligence with one of my peers. I tried to explain the premise that a Business Intelligence application in our industry (Health Care) should not be a one-size-fits all solution. Instead the technology should be tailored to the types of questions that it will need to answer most frequently.

When he claimed "of course it has to be able to answer any question, otherwise we could just write queries," I realized I failed to make my point. He is not the first person I've met to have this opinion. In fact, the opinion is pretty pervasive among my peers; and it is wrong.

Our Business Intelligence solution is a textbook case highlighting this point. Its' saga is a story for another day, but in our attempt to make it very flexible we failed to make it strong. That is, there's no limit to the reports you can create, but it's not great at answering any particular question.

I liken this to the difference between a hammer and a Swiss Army Knife. A hammer is great at driving nails, better than any other tool for this task. It also happens to be pretty good at removing nails too. A Swiss Army knife can do a lot of things from clipping nails to opening cans. But it's not particularly good at any of them.

The real beauty of a hammer, though, is the other things that it can do pretty well. In fact, if put to the test, it isn't hard to come up with at least as many tasks as can be done with a hammer as with the Swiss Army Knife. It can be a door-stop, a paper-weight, a meat tenderizer, a garden shovel, and more. Sure, it's lousy at tightening screws, but it can really drive nails.

Don't get me wrong. There's a place for firms that build all-in-one software. In fact, my former employer Information Builders is one such firm. My current BI solution is built on a MicroStrategy platform, another Swiss Army Knife vendor. Vertical solutions, like our health care application, need to be targeted; they need to be really good at particular questions.

Unfortunately, many designers of Business Intelligence solutions try to make Swiss Army Knives when they really need hammers. And given a good hammer and an innovative user, there will soon be many other tasks suitable for the tool.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

I might have saved a life

I might have saved a life today. In truth, my actions were more instinctive than intentional; I had prevented a stranger from being struck by a car by grabbing his coat as he stepped off a Manhattan curb and into traffic. The oncoming car was speeding fast down the narrow street, trying to make a green light. The stranger was concentrating on his iPhone and was oblivious to the danger. It was unlikely that the driver could have stopped in time, and the man surely would have been struck. He was shaken after the incident and thanked me, claiming I saved his life.

Later, as I replayed the scene, I wondered about the thought process that led to my grabbing a complete stranger and pulling him back out of harm's way. Of course it happened so fast that I was not conscious of the decisions I had to make. In short, I saw a speeding car and an unaware pedestrian and naturally reached out to prevent the accident. But were my actions natural? Sure, it was easy to access the danger of the situation, but the choice to grab the man was selected over other possibilities. I could have shouted a warning; I could have done nothing and hoped for the best; or I could have alerted the driver.

At first blush my decision seems obvious among the choices. Still, though, there was more information to process. I had to decide that the probability the man would be struck was very high. And I had to weigh the risk of him getting hurt against the chance that he would take offense at being forcibly grabbed by a stranger. This last point is trickier than it may seem, because I had to judge that it was appropriate to touch him and I wonder how I would have reacted if it was a different person. Would I grab a woman in the same way? Would I a grab a homeless person? Is the fact that he was a man similar to me a factor in saving him from injury? I like to think that I would react the same regardless of the person at harm.

In the end the only thing that matters was the man did not get injured. I suppose it was nice, too, that he was appreciative.

Every second

Every now and then I come across a web site that seems like nonsense, but then turns out kind of cool. Such is the case with every second, a simple web site with several animations representing events in the world (or universe).

Visually, the site is attractive; it is rendered in gray-scale with a modern sans-serif font. There is one UI anomaly though, the links for Category, and item seemed reversed. But once you get past the odd click arrangement the site is pretty cool.

Cool yes, but not terribly useful. Maybe it is nonsense after all.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Sad saga of a three and a half hour commute

Wrong decisions aren't necessarily bad decisions. After all, choosing to walk from Maze on 54Th street to Penn Station on a beautiful night isn't a bad decision. As it turned out, though, is was the wrong decision. So shortly before 10pm I set out on foot to enjoy the night and sights of midtown Manhattan.

A wise man would have checked his watch. And a wise man would know the train schedule. I did not check either my watch or the schedule; two mistakes I should not make as a seasoned commuter. 

As it turns out, these were unfortunate errors because I arrived at Penn Station just minutes after my train had left. The next train was at 11:18pm, just under an hour wait.

Penn Station in New York is not a very pleasant place. During the day is bustles with activity as commuters pour out in the morning and pour back in later. Commuters are like automatons; showing little emotion they rush to their destination trying to interact with other as little as possible. There is nothing interesting or pretty about the station, it is completely utilitarian. At night it is a popular hang-out for the homeless. I spent my hour in the NJ Transit waiting area with my nose to my BlackBerry.

When the train was available for boarding, I found a quiet seat near the back and promptly fell asleep. I was awakened later by the conductor's announcement that our train had lost power. We had made it as far as the Secaucus transfer station; in the middle on the New Jersey swamps. The train was dead and the next one would be an hour wait.

By time I was home, it was 2am in the morning. After a half hour walk through Manhattan, an hour wait at Penn Station, an hour wait after my train was disabled, and an hour train ride home. Commuting is a bitch. But had I decided to take a cab to Penn Station, or even jump on the subway, I would have caught the 10:18 train and would have been snuggled in bed before midnight. Instead I made a wrong decision and paid the consequences.


Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Somebody agrees with my Chrome prediction

When Google introduced its' Chrome browser, I posted a short article on my thoughts (see Thoughts on Google Chrome). One of my conclusions was that the browser which would most feel competitive pressure would by FireFox.

"...If my browsing patterns are common, though, then Firefox will suffer more. In the end, Firefox and Chrome may just duke it out..."

Today I read an article with a similar conclusion. I'm happy that someone out there agrees.

The article, though, overlooks the primary reason why IE will remain the dominate browser; the fact remains that a huge library of browser based applications are not cross-browser (case in point, my team's products). This software is not aimed at the consumer or deployed on the World Wide Web. Instead the applications are deployed on corporate intranets around the world, assuring that IE remains the browser of choice for IT departments.

Monday, February 09, 2009

Meme

My introduction to YouTube was a viral video titled "Boom Goes the Dynamite". As it turned out, the video became part of Internet lore, and the term part of American vernacular. There are dozens of similar videos that have become what is called "meme" (pronounced meem). For those of us who quickly delete chain email, or don't have the inclination to follow viral stories, there is a source for the most significant meme, KnowYourMeme.

Know your meme is more than a collection of YouTube links. They have their own videos hosted by geeks in lab coats. They describe the source of the meme, show clips from the original source, and even follow-up on some of the near-celebrities. Check it out and never get left out of idle conversations again.

Thursday, February 05, 2009

More web nonsense I don't need but will probably sign-up for anyway

Google has recently announced Latitude. This service allows you to track your friend's location using Google Maps. At first blush, I would categorize this service much like Twitter, as one of the dumbest services on the Web.

I'm a bit of a hypocrite when it comes to Twitter. I use it to update my Facebook status from my cell phone. As yet, though, I don't see how Latitude will provide a similar benefit and I don't think my friends will care about my exact location. Maybe my boss can use it to see how freely I come and go.

Latitude smacks a little like Big Brother. Google is famous for its' don't be evil mantra, but it this type of information will provide a lot of temptation for misuse. Privacy advocates will hate the service. In the end, joining and sharing the information will be voluntary, so I guess users will make their own trouble.

As for me, I'll kick the tires a bit, but you can bet that the service will be turned on my kids phones.

Wednesday, February 04, 2009

Some cool green transportation

An RSS from Fast Company just popped into my inbox. It describes the coolest electric vehicle I've seen. This is no Prius dork-mobile; no it's a hot super-bike capable of using it's electric motor for mind numbing acceleration. The bike is from Mission Motors, but go to Fast Company for the low-down.

Natural oraffice surgey; maybe it's cool, but it gives me the creeps

Apparently Johns Hopkins research doctors have successfully removed a kidney through, um, the donor's oraffice. It's called "transvaginal nephrectomy" or, more broadly, "natural orifice" surgery. In the case of us guys, the idea would be to use the rectum.

The procedure reduces external damage or injury to the donor. The necessary incisions are smaller. Recovery time is quicker. And pain in reduced.

While the benefits seems positive, it still gives me the "willies" to think that someday I could donate a kidney out of my butt. 

Monday, January 26, 2009

Engaging the entrepreneurial power of employees with a venture capital model

The entrepreneur in us sees opportunities everywhere we look, but many people see only problems everywhere they look. The entrepreneur in us is more concerned with discriminating between opportunities than he or she is with failing to see the opportunities - Michael Gerber, author, entrepreneur

This year I participated, in an innovative project as we prepared for review by an internal leadership team. As of this writing, the project is not approved, but the financials are very strong and the technology is very low risk. By the time the project is reviewed by the board later this year, my firm will have spent nearly 18 months, hundreds of man-hours, and tens of thousands of dollars. Yet the work product produced is merely a document and an idea. There is no code and no proof of concept.

The procedure is at best a difficult process; at its’ worst an impossible process. There should be little doubt that the net effect of the process is to inhibit growth through innovation. It is, in fact, a barrier to entry for teams with go-to-market ideas.

Industry is full of companies with high profile examples of innovation. Firms like Google, Pixar, GE, and Apple show that a culture of innovation can bring success. This paper describes how any firm can evolve into a venture driven company that empowers employees with an entrepreneurial spirit.

The goal is plain and simple: achieve explosive growth through a culture of innovation.

To foster this culture, I suggest a model based on capital markets for startup companies. There are three aspects to this proposal:

  • The corporation acts as a Hedge Fund by allocating funds for investment and measuring  aggregate results;
  • Senior executives function as Venture Capitalists by soliciting ideas and managing a portfolio of investments; and
  • Employees become the Entrepreneurs championing their ideas and finding resources to execute a project.

 

The critical ingredient is getting off your butt and doing something. It's as simple as that. A lot of people have ideas, but there are few who decide to do something about them now. Not tomorrow. Not next week. But today. The true entrepreneur is a doer, not a dreamer - Nolan Bushnell, founder of Atari and Chuck E. Cheese's

The Hedge Fund

A hedge fund is a private investment fund whose managers can make speculative investment and participate in profits from money invested. The company can function much like a hedge fund by structuring projects as a portfolio of investments. The managers of the “hedge fund” are the executives who normally vet within for the company.

The corporation, then, decides how much to invest in the fund. Each year these funds are set aside for innovation and it becomes the responsibility of the hedge fund managers to assure the funds are invested, and that the portfolio achieves an appropriate return.

As the Hedge Fund, the company would:

  • Invest in the fund by allocating monies for innovation. An investment to the innovation fund each year;
  • Appoint  executives to function as the Venture Capitalists;
  • Set an ROI threshold for the fund

Taking Risk

I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work - Thomas Edison, inventor and scientist

A great percentage of start-ups fail. Hedge funds that specialize in innovation spread their investments over a wide range of projects with the understanding that a small number of winners will earn a return for the entire portfolio. Risky projects will be an integral part of the firm’s portfolio.

Like true VC hedge funds, the firm can mitigate risk by funding projects that already have some track record of success. This track record could be a successful competitor, a custom built technology, or a joint venture with a client.

Exit Strategies

Unlike the holdings in venture capital hedge funds, the company’s investments generally do not end with a liquidity event (sale of the company or IPO).Instead successful investments will result in product lines or business that generate revenue and profit. Less successful projects are absorbed into existing businesses or closed outright.

It should be noted that there is the possibility of a liquidity event. Although these may be rare, some projects could be spun off as independent companies. In such cases the firm would act as a private equity fund, holding a stake in the company until an appropriate liquidity event occurs.

Venture Capitalists

Since one fails often, address markets that make it worthwhile when one does succeed. Vinod Khosla, co-founder of Sun Microsystems

Executives that normally vet for capital investment will serve as the venture capitalists in this model. As VC, each executive is expected to oversee a portfolio of projects and to assure that their funds are invested. Each VC would have a specialty where they would focus their investments. It would be expected, though, that they would invest outside their area on occasion.

The VC has four primary roles:

  • Invest a share of the fund in projects of their choosing;
  • Provide oversight of the projects in their portfolio;
  • Mentor the entrepreneurs assigned to the projects in their portfolio; and
  • Arrange exit strategies for their projects.

Key to the success of the hedge fund is the oversight and mentoring role of the VC. Unlike an “approve-and-forget” capital investment model, VCs of the hedge fund share responsibility for the success of their portfolio. This oversight keeps entrepreneurs accountable to accomplish milestones and meet their financial goals.

VCs solicit, review, and select projects based on the business plan from the entrepreneur. The VCs is empowered and required to invest his share of the fund.  VCs will be expected to accomplish the appropriate due diligence, but being empowered will make the decision process move quickly. With empowerment comes accountability, and the VC will be expected to make rational decisions based on standard venture criteria such as, experience of management, amount of existing business, size of the market, first-in status, and the competitive landscape.

Like true VCs, the managers in the firm’s hedge fund will collaborate on some projects. Some of the VCs will assume an “angle investor” role by making small investments in a large set of projects in their early stages. As angle projects progress, the VC may decide to invest additional rounds of financing. Also, several VCs may invest together in a project, thereby sharing the risk, or implementing a large scale innovation.

VCs shall participate is the financial success of their portfolio. A bonus would be paid based on the success of the projects in the portfolio.

I never perfected an invention that I did not think about in terms of the service it might give others... I find out what the world needs, then I proceed to invent -Thomas Edison, inventor and scientist

Intrapreneurs

Some people dream of great accomplishments, while others stay awake and do them – Anonymous

Entrepreneur : one who organizes, manages, and assumes the risks of a business or enterprise.

Intrapreneur : one who organizes, manages, and assumes the risks of an idea within a business or enterprise.

The entrepreneurs are the employees that champion an idea (intrapreneur is a term made up for this white paper). Entrepreneurs are passionate about an idea, and work to see it through to its completion. This includes building prototypes, writing business plans, seeking funding from VCs, and managing the project day-to-day.

Much of the motivation and reward of these employees is intrinsic and non-financial. This includes the excitement of working on a new and innovative idea. In addition, once funding is approved, the employee will have effectively transferred into a new position with the company. Like the VC, however, the entrepreneur will be rewarded based on the financial success of the project or its exit strategy.

The entrepreneur has the following roles:

  • Develop a business plan;
  • Seek and obtain funding from the company VCs;
  • Build prototypes and proof-of-concepts for the project;
  • Obtain resources needed to complete the project;
  • Manage the project, day-to-day; and
  • Report progress and financial results to the VC

 

It should be expected that projects are present by a team of employees. In these cases, one member of the team shall be designated as the entrepreneur. It is likely that the entrepreneurs are employees that already hold management or leadership positions (but that are not a requirement).

Mitigating Personal Risk

Entrepreneurs assume a great deal of personal risk with regard to the security of their career. Although positions cannot be held open for the entrepreneur pending completion of their project, the corporation should guarantee that a position will be made available regardless of the success or failure of the project. Truly motivated entrepreneurs, however, do not consider failure, and will pursue the idea under the assumption of success.

The Business Plan

Entrepreneurs must submit a business plan to obtain funding for their projects. Business plans should follow common standards for start-up plans. At a minimum, a business plan shall include:

  • Description of the Idea;
  • Marketing Plan;
    • List of existing customers
    • List of target customers
    • Size of the market
    • Pricing
  • Competitive Analysis
    • List of competitors
    • Advantages and Disadvantages
  • Operational Plan
    • Management Team
    • Personnel
    • Technology
  • Financial Plan
    • Start-up Expenses
    • 3 Year Pro-Forma

 

Advantages of the Hedge Fund Model

This approach to funding invention, and building a culture of innovation has distinct advantages over my company’s current model.

  • The current procedure in of itself is an expensive and labor intense process. It requires multiple stages of presentation and approval. The current process is self-regulating, scaring away employees that are intimidated by the process regardless of the quality of their idea.
  • An innovation provides a method of easily submitting an idea, but except for quick rejections, it routes ideas through the same burdensome approval process.
  • The hedge fund model is simple; write a business plan and present it to a VC.
  • Our current procedure is slow.  It will be very difficult to have first-in status if seeking funding through the current process. Real-time Fraud and Abuse, for example, has been in-process for months.
  • The hedge fund model is fast.
  • Where our current procedure is focused on preparation and planning during the approval process, hedge fund is focused on execution of the idea.
  • Hedge fund rewards entrepreneurs and VCs for taking risk and accomplishing goals.
  • Hedge fund provides a tangible portfolio of innovation and R&D.
  • Hedge fund is based on tried and true practices of bring an idea to market.

 

Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover -Mark Twain, author

Monday, October 13, 2008

Twitter gives up on Instant Messaging (for now)

Twitter, one of Web 2.0's most pointless sites, is giving up on their Instant Messaging capability. According to their status page, Twitter is changing the classification of the feature from something needing a fix to something they will build. Apparently their implementation of the feature is neither scalable nor reliable.

Twitter's existence is based on their invention of "micro-blogging." Micro blogs are short notes posted in response to the question "what are you doing." Beyond the concept of a micro-blog Twitter makes it easy to submit updates through their web site or via an SMS message. Instant messaging is simply another way to post the tiny blogs.

The relevance of Twitter has to come into question. Certainly Facebook's news feed serves the same purpose, and is much more common. In fact, most of my Twitter posting are made through the Twitter Facebook application. Maybe it's me, but I believe the real value to Twitter is it's ability to post comments via several easy to use methods. Instant messaging is one of those sources and should be an urgent capability to add. Otherwise the company will lose any relevance to others providing a similar service as part of a greater offering.

Friday, September 05, 2008

Thoughts on Google Chrome

A couple of years ago, a friend of mine said "everything Google does is excellent". He was showing me Google Maps, which at that time, was revolutionary. Until then, I considered Google another search vendor of Yahoo and Alta Vista ilk. Shortly thereafter I signed up for Google Mail (remember when it was by invitation only), then Google Talk, and later Google Docs.

Although I like Google Docs a lot, using it made me realize that not everything from Google is excellent. And that sums up my opinion about Google's new browser, Chrome. While I like it, and am using it a lot, it's not excellent…yet.

I downloaded and installed Chrome shortly after it was made publicly available this week. Like everything that Google does, the download and installation was fast and automatic. Getting started is easy. Regardless of their claims, Chrome is really just another browser. But true to the Google brand, the browser excels at search. Sure the integrated address and search bar is nice, but IE and firefox let you search from the address bar too. The search feature I really like is the within a page; I like the way Chrome highlights hits on the scrollbar.

Two days is not a lot of time to work with a program, and being a new application in a mature market, Chrome is expected to have flaws. Here some of the issues that I found:

  • Sites that perform browser sniffing don't render properly. Hotmail, for instance, only supports its' classic html mode. And our FogBugz issue tracking software refuses to run its' Wiki in Chrome.
  • Facebook applications behave oddly, in particular I found that links and buttons, such as "Allow" or "Ignore" fail.
  • Our web applications developed by my teams do not render well, but then they don't render well in FireFox either. We remain a Microsoft shop.
  • Silverlight applications do not run in Chrome, so Google surfers can't see pictures of my family.
  • There's no history list, at least not without typing the first few characters of a web site.
  • There's no button to display a home page; well Ok, there's a setting but it's off by default.
  • I can't (and maybe it's just me) get back to the frequent-page thumbnails without opening a new tab. I want to make this my home page.

I find it interesting that Google chose to enter the browser market. Do we need another browser? It's only been a couple of years since Internet Explorer was the only real player. If Chrome catches on there will be four; IE, Firefox, Safari, and Chrome (nah, I don't count Opera). Personally, I find myself gravitating to Chrome despite its' flaws and am considering making it my default browser. Although I use Internet Explorer a bit less I find that I never open Firefox anymore (I have Safari for Windows, but really, who uses that?); this after only two days with Chrome.

The competitive target of Chrome is Internet Explorer, and certainly the Chrome comic book takes shots at IE weaknesses. If my browsing patterns are common, though, then Firefox will suffer more. In the end, Firefox and Chrome may just duke it out for the (tiny but vocal) anti-Microsoft crowd. I heard a rumor that Google's entry into the browser space is a precursor to their entry into PDA's with Android. In much the same way that Apple leveraged Safari on the iPhone, Google will leverage Chrome. And on a tiny cell phone screen Chrome's quirkiness will be unimportant. The cell phone angle is intriguing, but Google's open platform approach will produce odd devices and applications that will seem crude when compared to Apple's cohesive offering. If nothing else, Google is making the software industry fun again.

You might also like ...