Lessons learned from twentyfive years building software, recruiting teams, and managing growing firms.
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
Somebody agrees with my Chrome prediction
Monday, February 09, 2009
Meme
Thursday, February 05, 2009
More web nonsense I don't need but will probably sign-up for anyway
Wednesday, February 04, 2009
Some cool green transportation
Natural oraffice surgey; maybe it's cool, but it gives me the creeps
Monday, January 26, 2009
Engaging the entrepreneurial power of employees with a venture capital model
The entrepreneur in us sees opportunities everywhere we look, but many people see only problems everywhere they look. The entrepreneur in us is more concerned with discriminating between opportunities than he or she is with failing to see the opportunities - Michael Gerber, author, entrepreneur
This year I participated, in an innovative project as we prepared for review by an internal leadership team. As of this writing, the project is not approved, but the financials are very strong and the technology is very low risk. By the time the project is reviewed by the board later this year, my firm will have spent nearly 18 months, hundreds of man-hours, and tens of thousands of dollars. Yet the work product produced is merely a document and an idea. There is no code and no proof of concept.
The procedure is at best a difficult process; at its’ worst an impossible process. There should be little doubt that the net effect of the process is to inhibit growth through innovation. It is, in fact, a barrier to entry for teams with go-to-market ideas.
Industry is full of companies with high profile examples of innovation. Firms like Google, Pixar, GE, and Apple show that a culture of innovation can bring success. This paper describes how any firm can evolve into a venture driven company that empowers employees with an entrepreneurial spirit.
The goal is plain and simple: achieve explosive growth through a culture of innovation.
To foster this culture, I suggest a model based on capital markets for startup companies. There are three aspects to this proposal:
- The corporation acts as a Hedge Fund by allocating funds for investment and measuring aggregate results;
- Senior executives function as Venture Capitalists by soliciting ideas and managing a portfolio of investments; and
- Employees become the Entrepreneurs championing their ideas and finding resources to execute a project.
The critical ingredient is getting off your butt and doing something. It's as simple as that. A lot of people have ideas, but there are few who decide to do something about them now. Not tomorrow. Not next week. But today. The true entrepreneur is a doer, not a dreamer - Nolan Bushnell, founder of Atari and Chuck E. Cheese's
The Hedge Fund
A hedge fund is a private investment fund whose managers can make speculative investment and participate in profits from money invested. The company can function much like a hedge fund by structuring projects as a portfolio of investments. The managers of the “hedge fund” are the executives who normally vet within for the company.
The corporation, then, decides how much to invest in the fund. Each year these funds are set aside for innovation and it becomes the responsibility of the hedge fund managers to assure the funds are invested, and that the portfolio achieves an appropriate return.
As the Hedge Fund, the company would:
- Invest in the fund by allocating monies for innovation. An investment to the innovation fund each year;
- Appoint executives to function as the Venture Capitalists;
- Set an ROI threshold for the fund
Taking Risk
I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work - Thomas Edison, inventor and scientist
A great percentage of start-ups fail. Hedge funds that specialize in innovation spread their investments over a wide range of projects with the understanding that a small number of winners will earn a return for the entire portfolio. Risky projects will be an integral part of the firm’s portfolio.
Like true VC hedge funds, the firm can mitigate risk by funding projects that already have some track record of success. This track record could be a successful competitor, a custom built technology, or a joint venture with a client.
Exit Strategies
Unlike the holdings in venture capital hedge funds, the company’s investments generally do not end with a liquidity event (sale of the company or IPO).Instead successful investments will result in product lines or business that generate revenue and profit. Less successful projects are absorbed into existing businesses or closed outright.
It should be noted that there is the possibility of a liquidity event. Although these may be rare, some projects could be spun off as independent companies. In such cases the firm would act as a private equity fund, holding a stake in the company until an appropriate liquidity event occurs.
Venture Capitalists
Since one fails often, address markets that make it worthwhile when one does succeed. Vinod Khosla, co-founder of Sun Microsystems
Executives that normally vet for capital investment will serve as the venture capitalists in this model. As VC, each executive is expected to oversee a portfolio of projects and to assure that their funds are invested. Each VC would have a specialty where they would focus their investments. It would be expected, though, that they would invest outside their area on occasion.
The VC has four primary roles:
- Invest a share of the fund in projects of their choosing;
- Provide oversight of the projects in their portfolio;
- Mentor the entrepreneurs assigned to the projects in their portfolio; and
- Arrange exit strategies for their projects.
Key to the success of the hedge fund is the oversight and mentoring role of the VC. Unlike an “approve-and-forget” capital investment model, VCs of the hedge fund share responsibility for the success of their portfolio. This oversight keeps entrepreneurs accountable to accomplish milestones and meet their financial goals.
VCs solicit, review, and select projects based on the business plan from the entrepreneur. The VCs is empowered and required to invest his share of the fund. VCs will be expected to accomplish the appropriate due diligence, but being empowered will make the decision process move quickly. With empowerment comes accountability, and the VC will be expected to make rational decisions based on standard venture criteria such as, experience of management, amount of existing business, size of the market, first-in status, and the competitive landscape.
Like true VCs, the managers in the firm’s hedge fund will collaborate on some projects. Some of the VCs will assume an “angle investor” role by making small investments in a large set of projects in their early stages. As angle projects progress, the VC may decide to invest additional rounds of financing. Also, several VCs may invest together in a project, thereby sharing the risk, or implementing a large scale innovation.
VCs shall participate is the financial success of their portfolio. A bonus would be paid based on the success of the projects in the portfolio.
I never perfected an invention that I did not think about in terms of the service it might give others... I find out what the world needs, then I proceed to invent -Thomas Edison, inventor and scientist
Intrapreneurs
Some people dream of great accomplishments, while others stay awake and do them – Anonymous
Entrepreneur : one who organizes, manages, and assumes the risks of a business or enterprise.
Intrapreneur : one who organizes, manages, and assumes the risks of an idea within a business or enterprise.
The entrepreneurs are the employees that champion an idea (intrapreneur is a term made up for this white paper). Entrepreneurs are passionate about an idea, and work to see it through to its completion. This includes building prototypes, writing business plans, seeking funding from VCs, and managing the project day-to-day.
Much of the motivation and reward of these employees is intrinsic and non-financial. This includes the excitement of working on a new and innovative idea. In addition, once funding is approved, the employee will have effectively transferred into a new position with the company. Like the VC, however, the entrepreneur will be rewarded based on the financial success of the project or its exit strategy.
The entrepreneur has the following roles:
- Develop a business plan;
- Seek and obtain funding from the company VCs;
- Build prototypes and proof-of-concepts for the project;
- Obtain resources needed to complete the project;
- Manage the project, day-to-day; and
- Report progress and financial results to the VC
It should be expected that projects are present by a team of employees. In these cases, one member of the team shall be designated as the entrepreneur. It is likely that the entrepreneurs are employees that already hold management or leadership positions (but that are not a requirement).
Mitigating Personal Risk
Entrepreneurs assume a great deal of personal risk with regard to the security of their career. Although positions cannot be held open for the entrepreneur pending completion of their project, the corporation should guarantee that a position will be made available regardless of the success or failure of the project. Truly motivated entrepreneurs, however, do not consider failure, and will pursue the idea under the assumption of success.
The Business Plan
Entrepreneurs must submit a business plan to obtain funding for their projects. Business plans should follow common standards for start-up plans. At a minimum, a business plan shall include:
- Description of the Idea;
- Marketing Plan;
- List of existing customers
- List of target customers
- Size of the market
- Pricing
- Competitive Analysis
- List of competitors
- Advantages and Disadvantages
- Operational Plan
- Management Team
- Personnel
- Technology
- Financial Plan
- Start-up Expenses
- 3 Year Pro-Forma
Advantages of the Hedge Fund Model
This approach to funding invention, and building a culture of innovation has distinct advantages over my company’s current model.
- The current procedure in of itself is an expensive and labor intense process. It requires multiple stages of presentation and approval. The current process is self-regulating, scaring away employees that are intimidated by the process regardless of the quality of their idea.
- An innovation provides a method of easily submitting an idea, but except for quick rejections, it routes ideas through the same burdensome approval process.
- The hedge fund model is simple; write a business plan and present it to a VC.
- Our current procedure is slow. It will be very difficult to have first-in status if seeking funding through the current process. Real-time Fraud and Abuse, for example, has been in-process for months.
- The hedge fund model is fast.
- Where our current procedure is focused on preparation and planning during the approval process, hedge fund is focused on execution of the idea.
- Hedge fund rewards entrepreneurs and VCs for taking risk and accomplishing goals.
- Hedge fund provides a tangible portfolio of innovation and R&D.
- Hedge fund is based on tried and true practices of bring an idea to market.
Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover -Mark Twain, author
Monday, October 13, 2008
Twitter gives up on Instant Messaging (for now)
Twitter's existence is based on their invention of "micro-blogging." Micro blogs are short notes posted in response to the question "what are you doing." Beyond the concept of a micro-blog Twitter makes it easy to submit updates through their web site or via an SMS message. Instant messaging is simply another way to post the tiny blogs.
The relevance of Twitter has to come into question. Certainly Facebook's news feed serves the same purpose, and is much more common. In fact, most of my Twitter posting are made through the Twitter Facebook application. Maybe it's me, but I believe the real value to Twitter is it's ability to post comments via several easy to use methods. Instant messaging is one of those sources and should be an urgent capability to add. Otherwise the company will lose any relevance to others providing a similar service as part of a greater offering.
Friday, September 05, 2008
Thoughts on Google Chrome
A couple of years ago, a friend of mine said "everything Google does is excellent". He was showing me Google Maps, which at that time, was revolutionary. Until then, I considered Google another search vendor of Yahoo and Alta Vista ilk. Shortly thereafter I signed up for Google Mail (remember when it was by invitation only), then Google Talk, and later Google Docs.
Although I like Google Docs a lot, using it made me realize that not everything from Google is excellent. And that sums up my opinion about Google's new browser, Chrome. While I like it, and am using it a lot, it's not excellent…yet.
I downloaded and installed Chrome shortly after it was made publicly available this week. Like everything that Google does, the download and installation was fast and automatic. Getting started is easy. Regardless of their claims, Chrome is really just another browser. But true to the Google brand, the browser excels at search. Sure the integrated address and search bar is nice, but IE and firefox let you search from the address bar too. The search feature I really like is the within a page; I like the way Chrome highlights hits on the scrollbar.
Two days is not a lot of time to work with a program, and being a new application in a mature market, Chrome is expected to have flaws. Here some of the issues that I found:
- Sites that perform browser sniffing don't render properly. Hotmail, for instance, only supports its' classic html mode. And our FogBugz issue tracking software refuses to run its' Wiki in Chrome.
- Facebook applications behave oddly, in particular I found that links and buttons, such as "Allow" or "Ignore" fail.
- Our web applications developed by my teams do not render well, but then they don't render well in FireFox either. We remain a Microsoft shop.
- Silverlight applications do not run in Chrome, so Google surfers can't see pictures of my family.
- There's no history list, at least not without typing the first few characters of a web site.
- There's no button to display a home page; well Ok, there's a setting but it's off by default.
- I can't (and maybe it's just me) get back to the frequent-page thumbnails without opening a new tab. I want to make this my home page.
I find it interesting that Google chose to enter the browser market. Do we need another browser? It's only been a couple of years since Internet Explorer was the only real player. If Chrome catches on there will be four; IE, Firefox, Safari, and Chrome (nah, I don't count Opera). Personally, I find myself gravitating to Chrome despite its' flaws and am considering making it my default browser. Although I use Internet Explorer a bit less I find that I never open Firefox anymore (I have Safari for Windows, but really, who uses that?); this after only two days with Chrome.
The competitive target of Chrome is Internet Explorer, and certainly the Chrome comic book takes shots at IE weaknesses. If my browsing patterns are common, though, then Firefox will suffer more. In the end, Firefox and Chrome may just duke it out for the (tiny but vocal) anti-Microsoft crowd. I heard a rumor that Google's entry into the browser space is a precursor to their entry into PDA's with Android. In much the same way that Apple leveraged Safari on the iPhone, Google will leverage Chrome. And on a tiny cell phone screen Chrome's quirkiness will be unimportant. The cell phone angle is intriguing, but Google's open platform approach will produce odd devices and applications that will seem crude when compared to Apple's cohesive offering. If nothing else, Google is making the software industry fun again.
Tuesday, July 08, 2008
eWeek looks at Computing on the Cloud
My paper copy of eWeek is generally fodder for the circular file. In fact, the magazine rarely makes it as far as my office. Instead it stays in our reception area on a coffee table along with other unread magazines. This week, though, I picked up a couple of editions to browse while taking lunch. In the process I discovered some interesting cloud computing technologies.
The first is old news for leading edge developers, but new to me. The June 30 edition ran an analysis on the Google App Engine. The Google App Engine competes with Amazon Web Services in scope and intent. Although Google currently only supports the Python language, betting an application on Google infrastructure seems pretty safe.
In a similar vein, GigaSpaces offers an application server that sits on Amazon's EC2 cloud computing solution. The GigaSpaces application server provides a middleware layer between Java or .Net applications and the Amazon Web Services backend.
A third product, Jungle Disk, has a different goal, but uses computing on the cloud none-the-less. Jungle Disk is a backup and storage solution that works with Amazon's S3 Web Service. I have not tried Jungle Disk, but eWeek offers a fairly thorough analysis that puts the product on my to-do list.
Of course the interesting common thread with all these applications is computing on the cloud. GigaSpaces and Jungle Disk take advantage of Amazon's early entry into the utility computing space. Google, however, does everything well, and should have little trouble catching up. Old timers like myself remember the days of time-sharing on mainframes. Cloud computing proves what's old is new again with one important difference; now utility computing is affordable.
Thursday, July 03, 2008
Once You’re Lucky
I often pick books based on reviews from Wired Magazine. This was true when I picked up Once You're Lucky, Twice You're Good. In Mark Horowitz's review, he claimed that "Sarah Lacy…hangs with [entrepreneurs] them, gains their trust, and gets the goods. No other recent chronicle delivers such intimate, behind-the-scene glimpses into Silicon Valley startup life." It's an entertaining read reminiscent of Accidental Empires.
My issue with the current crop of valley startups has little to do with Sarah Lacy's book, although her tales reinforce my opinion. The problem is very few of the companies actually provide a site that is useful. Even Facebook, the current reigning king of Web 2.0, doesn't help its members solve problems or get things done. Of course my days of finding a good off-campus kegger with lots of girls are long past. As Twitter, Slide, or Ning they seem even less useful.
What's interesting about these sites, though, and the stories Sarah wraps around them, is the underlying technology. Maybe an old-timer like myself doesn't see the benefit of social networking. I do see where collaboration and go anywhere sites can be very useful. I'm expecting a new wave of web startups that take Web 2.0 into truly commercially viable areas.
Monday, June 30, 2008
Thoughts on Innovation
It is not easy to foster a culture of innovation in a corporation. Ironically, I have not always felt this way. I have spent the great majority of my career at start-ups, entrepreneurial charged companies, and software makers. Each of these environments relied on the creativity of their people to remain competitive.
When I joined my current firm, we were a small and hungry software supplier in the HealthCare industry. We served a particular niche market and our growth was dependent upon finding new and inventive ways to sell more products into this niche. In my first year with the firm we doubled our number of offerings.
Something happened to that culture of invention when we were swallowed by a bigger fish. It's hard to put a finger on it, but maybe it's our build vs. buy strategy that favors buy over build. Maybe it's our market dominance and entrenched legacy customer base. Maybe it's a culture that meticulously tracks where each hour of engineering time is spent.
You can start with the existing method of starting a project around a new idea. A rigid and exhaustive procedure was established to analyze projects for funding. The firm sets aside money especially for these projects. But the process is long, bureaucratic, and daunting. Only those employees with the greatest perseverance can weather the multiple stages, detailed requirements, and long delays of this process. The process itself, then, serves to prevent innovation.
It's not that the company is not interested in innovation. This year the firm initiated a council of thinkers who are charged with encouraging the submission of creative ideas. On the surface you might think the initiative could be very successful, but I see some fundamental flaws that could stall our efforts.
First and foremost of the flaws is the establishment of yet another process. And what happens when an idea passes through the process established by the idea team? The idea is handed off to the same process as before, but possibly skipping the first stage. In affect we have put a new process in front of the old process. If the old process was a deterrent to innovation, then the new one is doubly so.
Add to the mess of procedures, a subtle lack of focus. This lack of focus was exposed by our firm's COO who made it apparent her goal is innovation in operations. The Japanese auto industry of the 1980s was cited as an example. This is fine enough, except the council had established criteria around the analysis of new product ideas. In other words, we were looking externally for innovation, when the COO expected us to look internally. The criteria to judge projects of these two types are dramatically different.
So far, the results of our council are disappointing. No idea has successfully come to fruition. And the promotion of an innovative culture is stalled.
Of course everyone holds up Google as the standard. Even among my staff, I've tried to encourage the idea of spending 20% of our time on new ideas. The key to the Google concept, though, isn't necessarily the allocation of time. Instead it's the thinking that with a new idea, many people "won't get it", at least not at first. The idea has to go through some element of trial and error before it can be tabled or killed. This is in direct contrast to our approach, which puts rigorous paperwork between the idea and a prototype.
If we really want innovation to take hold at our company, we'll need to change the model. We'll need to empower people to spend time building working versions of their idea, instead of filing a form. We'll need a little of the "just do it" attitude, instead of waiting for approvals. I guess we'll need to regain a some of our entrepreneurial mojo.
Friday, June 20, 2008
Thoughts on some Web 2.0 Sites
The expression Web 2.0 has been with us so long that we can consider it a Tired term. Founded on the principles of collaboration, and built on highly interactive technology (read AJAX), Web 2.0 sites represent the post bubble rebirth of an industry. Some of these sites offer fairly valuable services and some of them are nonsense. Here are my thoughts…
Facebook is seen as the company with the most potential for long term success. I've been using the site almost daily for over a month and I can honestly say that "I don't get it". Sure, I'm a bit of a dinosaur, having attended college (both degrees) long before social networking came to the web. But in all my use of the site over the last several weeks, it hasn't helped me accomplish anything. Facebook has been pretty successful at positioning itself as a platform for micro-applications. Here again, I don't get it. I've tried many of the applications and always end up with the same thought…"so what?". I read somewhere that everyone eventually has an "ah-ha" moment with social networking; I'm still waiting for mine with Facebook.
On the contrary I saw the benefit to LinkedIn the day I started using it nearly five years ago. This site has helped me find work, consultants, and business leads. I've heard it called social networking for business people, but there's really very little that social about it. The site generally prevents people from contacting strangers, at least without an introduction. Ironically, you can pay money to override this fundamental aspect of the site. Paying members have access to InMail messages and can reach out to people directly. Anyone in a career should be active on LinkedIn.
Plaxo is an odd hybrid of Facebook and LinkedIn. I actually avoided using Plaxo for sometime, opting instead for GoodContacts, but when GoodContacts looked like they weren't going to make it, I switched loyalties. Plaxo suffers from an identity crisis. It started as a convenient way of managing business and personal contacts online. I use it as my main address book, and sync Outlook, my Blackberry, and other sites to Plaxo. Somewhere along the way, though, the site morphed into Plaxo Pulse. The new site is a clone of Facebook, right down to the page layout and color scheme. I still use it to keep my address list, but I don't think this company will survive.
Geni is a cute social networking site for families. I checked it out after reading Once You're Lucky. This site is actually pretty good. It is easy to use and has all the capabilities needed to stay in touch with your extended family. Nonetheless I feel this site is doomed. I make this judgment simply because no one seems to know anything about it. My family is so tired of receiving web site invitations from me that they've all but ignored the Geni invites. And without active participation from my family, the site loses its' usefulness. Add in the fact that there is no subscription or advertising; I have no clue how the site expects to earn revenue.
Twitter is dumbest idea I've ever seen. Still, it's pretty addictive. I checked it out because I am starting a project that requires a similar SMS interface. My project, however, will be useful, where Twitter simply generates noise.
I have a love/hate relationship with Flickr. I use the site a lot by storing all my family's pictures there. I uploaded so many pictures that I had to buy a subscription. Flickr was a leader in establishing sharing, but now its UI seems dated. I find it difficult to use, or at least difficult to learn how to use. And I am disappointed in the site's "badge" ability; that led me to seek alternatives including Slide.
Krugle on the other hand is one of the best and most useful sites I've found. Of course you have to be a programmer to appreciate the site's benefits, but for those of us developing software for a living the site is amazing. Forget Google Code Search; Krugle is the place to go for snippets of code and projects in the public domain.
YouTube is silly and innocent fun. If you're reading this far into this post, then you already know all about YouTube.
Some people claim that Google Docs is meant to replace Microsoft Office. Google, of course, denies such claims by saying that Google Docs are meant to augment productivity suites. Frankly I don't care about the pending Microsoft vs Google wars. I like Office and I like Google Docs. I've read that Google Docs is not as feature rich as Office, and certainly the Google toolbar has nowhere near the number of buttons as the Office Ribbon. That said, I've never looked for a feature in Google Docs that it didn't have. I guess that says something for the feature bloat in Office.
Everybody uses maps online. MapQuest was amazing when it first came out. Google, however, really lifted the bar when it introduced Google Maps. Now all the map providers have full screen maps that pan as you drag them. They all have satellite pictures and zoom. Google has Street View and Live and Birdseye View. Of Google, Live, Yahoo! and MapQuest, I like Live best. But they're all good.
I checked out Slide because I wanted a cool way to show pictures on my web site. Slide has some cool features, but I was a little disappointed. I can't imagine building an entire business around slide shows so I don't look for this site to last long.
Popfly is Microsoft's site to demonstrate how cool their Silverlight technology is. It's kind of cool for developers building mashups and who don't mind using Microsoft technology. That's probably a pretty small group, but since I am technology agnostic, I use it and think it's a pretty cool site.
Delicious on the other hand is about as uncool as you can get. I think the site is ugly and serves little purpose. On the contrary, Trailfire, is of similar ilk but is amazing friendly and helpful. What a difference a thoughtful UI can make. Unfortunately, Delicious is the better bet for longevity in this space as they have the backing of Yahoo! and some web 2.0 brand recognition.
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Stay away from Fanbox
I am normally a proponent, and sometimes early adopter, of new technologies including Web Sites and Web Services. I'm also a believer in the value of personal networking. I have accounts all over the web including Face book, LinkedIn, and Plaxo Pulse. I've even signed up for some of the losers such as Friendster, Naymz, and Spaces. I never had a bad experience until I came across Fanbox (notice that I refuse to link to it).
It started with an innocent looking message from a colleague; Dawn has a question for you. When I clicked on the link, I was directed to Fanbox and presented a somewhat racy question that was apparently directed at someone with a much different demographic than me. Ironically I had been introduced to Fanbox a few days early by Sterling Brown and given Sterling's reputation I was intrigued. So I clicked on an answer to the question.
Here's a clue, if you get a message about a question, don't click on it! Answering the question kicked off a wizard inviting my contacts to Fanbox. Fanbox apparently scanned my Outlook Contact list, even though I never click a link for that purpose. It then asked if I me to send a question so I immediately clicked cancel. Later I discovered that Fanbox forwarded the question to my contacts and causing me much embarrassment.
It's really a shame because the fundamental technology of Fanbox is pretty cool. They have reproduced a workstation desktop and point-and-click user interface deployed over the web. The desktop comes with storage, email, and that mimic Microsoft Windows pretty closely. Apparently a Web-based Windows environment is a solution looking for a problem, because Fanbox has jumped on the social networking bandwagon. Outside of social networking, I did not see any real value to the site. There certainly is nothing that would persuade users of Facebook or Google Docs to jump to Fanbox.
So Fanbox has resorted to tricks to obtain members. Grabbing my contact list was akin to spyware or worm tactics. Maybe someday a company with vision will snatch up the Fanbox technology and deploy it provide some real benefit. Until then, avoid Fanbox like the plague.
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Brainteaser
See if you can solve this problem.
Each number shown below follows a certain rule. Figure out the rule and determine the missing number.
January | 20 |
March | 5 |
April | 10 |
December | 15 |
July | ? |
Is the answer?
- 5
- 10
- 15
- 20
- 25
Check back in a couple of days. I will post the answer in a comment.
Cash is King
There is a common notion that most start-ups fail for one of two reasons; either they are under capitalized or do not sell aggressively. In both these cases, the firm fails to raise the appropriate amount of cash needed to sustain operations. Of course all failed businesses run out of money, but some never give themselves a chance.
A firm that never gave itself was chance is Elite Technology Partners. The company was born from the technical brain trust of Blackwood Trading, and quickly conceived a product and business model based on their experience from the other firm. Their product was greatly inspired by Blackwood, but targeted a specific strategy and different distribution channel.
Elite's founders had learned from their experience at Blackwood. Certainly, they put to use the intellectual capital gained at Blackwood. They also learned from Blackwood's failed effort to market themselves successfully. In addition, the founders recognized that Blackwood's operational model was very expensive.
However, Elite underestimated the effort required to develop a product and bring it to market. Very quickly the firm fell into a chicken and egg situation. In Elite's case, they couldn't sell product because they did not have the capital to complete it. And they could not raise cash through sales because their product was not finished. Add to their situation the economic environment during 2002, where investment capital had effectively dried up. Venture capitalists were only looking at firms generating cash through sales.
In Elite's case, the lack of cash led to a series of strategies changes that sealed the fate of the company. First, a shortage of cash caused many of their best engineers to secure positions at other employers. Elite sought an investment arrangement through key prospects that would enable them to bring their product to market. But partnerships with a large investment come with restrictions. Demands of exclusive use and ownership of intellectual property made partnership deals impractical.
To raise cash, Elite sold its' talent in consulting arrangements. The consulting business was profitable and brought in enough cash to keep the operating. Unfortunately the opportunity cost of consulting was a halt to further development of Elite's product. In the end, Elite failed to complete its' product; Elite failed to complete its' product because it failed to raise the capital necessary to build the necessary technology.
I am working with an entrepreneur who is in a similar position. He is following a conscious strategy of delaying raising despite having an established relationship with investment bankers. The entrepreneur is betting that signed contracts will make the firm more attractive to investors. This may be true, but having no cash in his firm, he will have a difficult time meeting any operational commitments.
My observations of Elite Technology Partners leads me to believe that my friend has a risky strategy. Because he refuses to seek capital, he will not have a fully functional team in place when he signs his first contract. When the contract is signed he will need to complete his technology, hire staff, and seek capital within a very short timeframe. In the three to six months needed to receive private equity cash his venture could fail.
Elite Technology Partners failed because they did not raise cash for their operations. Successful entrepreneurs beg, borrow, or steal (Ok, maybe not steal) enough to give their companies inertia. A firm with inertia will attract further investment, or generate cash organically.
Tuesday, March 25, 2008
Here’s a Good Read
I just finished Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely. The book has to be one of my most favorite non-fiction reads. I have to admit that Mr. Ariely had me engaged from the first page of the introduction.
Here's the premise; we believe we make perfectly informed decisions, but truth be told we are a product of our nature. That nature makes decisions that are irrational; not only are our decisions irrational, but they are irrational in a consist manner. Through over a dozen chapters supported by controlled experiment, Ariely makes his point that our choices are behavioral.
Do you know why we so often promise ourselves to diet and exercise, only to have the thought vanish when the dessert cart rolls by?
Do you know why we sometimes find ourselves excitedly buying things we don't really need?
Do you know why we still have a headache after taking a five-cent aspirin, but why that same headache vanishes when the aspirin costs 50 cents?
Do you know why people who have been asked to recall the Ten Commandments tend to be more honest (at least immediately afterward) than those who haven't? Or why honor codes actually do reduce dishonesty in the workplace?
By the end of this book, you'll know the answers to these and many other questions that have implications for your personal life, for your business life, and for the way you look at the world. As a bonus you will also learn how much fun social science can be, and how to see more clearly the causes for our everyday behaviors, including the many cases in which we are predictably irrational.
Click here for more information.
I stumbled across the book while browsing "What We're Reading" on Slate. Check it out. In the meantime, I think I'll pay more attention to the books reviewed at Slate.
Friday, March 14, 2008
Middlesex
I recently finished the book Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides. The book is a Pulitzer Prize winner and Opra Book Club award winner. It is a well narrated but strange tale of a hermaphite exploring the roots of his condition.
It's hard to compare the story to another book. It spans three generation like many classic "come to America" novels. The subject matter will make some people uncomfortable, with its' thread of incest and gender confusion. In some ways I liken it to Running with Scissors, except that it is much more coherent and expertly told. Running with Scissor is more of a collection of oddball short stories written in a style of a middle-schooler.
I found myself drawn to the time period and location of the story. The narrator is my age, and grows up in the same metropolitan area as I did. References to Detroit places and events brought back memories of my own formative years.
Once started, I found the book hard to put down. I recommend it.
You might also like ...
-
I remember almost nothing about the morning of September 11th. It was my son's first day of school, but I don't recall thinking abo...
-
I am normally a proponent, and sometimes early adopter, of new technologies including Web Sites and Web Services. I'm also a believer in...
-
Apparently Johns Hopkins research doctors have successfully removed a kidney through, um, the donor's oraffice. It's called "tr...